Optimized Refactoring Mechanisms to Improve Quality Characteristics in Object-Oriented Systems

Refactoring has emerged as a predominant approach to augmenting software product quality. However, empirical evidence suggests that not all dimensions of software quality experience unending enhancements through refactoring. Current scholarly explorations reveal significant variances in the impacts of diverse refactoring methods, with potential adverse effects and contradictions surfacing concerning software quality. Consequently, such disparities render the advantages of refactoring contentious, culminating in challenges for software developers in the selection of optimal refactoring methods to ameliorate software quality. Existing literature lacks an in-depth exploration of the reasons behind the contrasting impacts of refactoring methods on quality enhancement or the development of refined protocols for employing these techniques. Therefore, this research aims to explore, identify, and fine-tune the utilization mechanisms of refactoring methods, empowering software developers to make informed choices for the enhancement of object-oriented systems’ quality attributes. Ten commonly employed refactoring methods were singled out for this investigation, each executed independently across five case studies varying in scale (small, medium, and large). The Quality Model for Object-Oriented Design (QMOOD) was employed as the evaluation tool to ascertain the influence of refactoring techniques on quality attributes. The research outcomes denote that the multifarious impacts of refactoring methods on quality attributes are attributed to distinct usage mechanisms of the techniques. These insights assist software practitioners in discerning the optimal utilization of refactoring methods to ameliorate software quality, taking their mechanisms into account. Moreover, these outcomes furnish industry experts with prescriptive guidelines for employing refactoring methods to elevate the quality of object-oriented systems, predicated on the suitable mechanism.