Rautenberg, Niclas Jonathan (2023) Colliding Worlds: Prolegomena to a Critical Phenomenology of Political Conflict. Doctoral thesis, University of Essex.
Rautenberg, Niclas Jonathan (2023) Colliding Worlds: Prolegomena to a Critical Phenomenology of Political Conflict. Doctoral thesis, University of Essex.
Rautenberg, Niclas Jonathan (2023) Colliding Worlds: Prolegomena to a Critical Phenomenology of Political Conflict. Doctoral thesis, University of Essex.
Abstract
Though political conflict is inevitable in democratic societies, it has garnered little attention in political philosophy as a phenomenon sui generis. In this PhD thesis, I survey the landscape of approaches to conflict and develop a critical-phenomenological basis for a more thorough philosophical understanding of the phenomenon. A key assumption is that the structures of conflict experience manifest in context-relative modalities shaped by power. To bring out these differences, I conducted qualitative interviews with political actors—politicians, civil servants, activists—which I analysed with the tools of phenomenology and critical theory. My dissertation reveals that agents can perceive the same conflict differently, at times drastically so, and explores how this variability impacts the suitability of practical proposals to resolve conflict. The dissertation is organised into five parts: (1) discusses a dominant paradigm in political philosophy, i.e., Rawlsian political liberalism. By uncovering its conflict typology, I show how intractable conflicts remain a problem in Rawls’s well-ordered society. (2) addresses Modus Vivendi Theory, i.e., a realist alternative approach. While I argue that the theory can potentially tackle a wider array of conflicts, it still remains too indeterminate to provide normative guidance. (3) marks a shift from immanent critique to a critical phenomenology of conflict. Focusing on the role of space and location in conflict, and combining phenomenology with feminism, the chapter shows how (a) variations relating to spaces matter for the viability of practical solutions to conflict; and (b) how power asymmetrically structures scopes of possible action in these spaces. (4) combines phenomenology and critical philosophy of race to illustrate the role of the body in conflict—both as the vehicle of action and as the object of social perception. (5) elaborates the normativity of the political world, developing a phenomenologically-informed understanding of political conflict missing in the literature.
Item Type: | Thesis (Doctoral) |
---|---|
Subjects: | B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > B Philosophy (General) J Political Science > JC Political theory |
Divisions: | Faculty of Humanities > Philosophy and Art History, School of |
Depositing User: | Niclas Rautenberg |
Date Deposited: | 09 Jun 2023 15:07 |
Last Modified: | 09 Jun 2023 15:07 |
URI: | http://repository.essex.ac.uk/id/eprint/35766 |
Available files
Filename: Rautenberg_PhD Thesis_Colliding Worlds_Prolegomena to a Critical Phenomenology of Political Conflict_final.pdf